← Issues index

9. Premium stories: spinner instead of body in server HTML — Low (PV) (lowered 16 Nov 2026)

Verified 16 Nov 2026: rendered as Googlebot (headless Chrome), a premium story (/technology/tech-tips/paper-battery-…-4306823) shows 115 of 397 words plus the subscribe prompt; the server also truncates to 115 words for everyone (app/server/data-loaders/story-page-data.js:92 @ 70d7bebf). Same content for Google and users, so no cloaking risk. Premium is 658 of 38,193 recent stories (1.7%) and they perform well (93% get Discover impressions; checks/traffic_funnel/report_pv_2026-11-13.md). Optional: restore hasPart (deleted in seo-hard-gate.js:274,291).

story-elements/index.js (~887–894): for access === "subscription" (non-ad-free) the whole body is replaced by <SpinnerLoader /> until a 500 ms timer and client-side premium-card computation. Server HTML for premium stories therefore has no body; premium content is also client-truncated (paywall). None of the tested pages were premium. 🔍 Check a premium URL in Search Console; review paywall structured data (isAccessibleForFree: false + hasPart) so Google can index premium content correctly.

17 Nov 2026: DH premium stories also have almost no body text in server HTML (0–13 words inside <p> on 6 sampled premium stories, Googlebot UA), while their AMP copies carry the full 534–1,178 words with no paywall. See #40.