← Issues index

15. Field CLS above lab CLS on two PV articles — explained by scroll-time shifts, merged into #5 — Medium (PV), via #5

Revised 19 Nov 2026. The original claim (field CLS "far above lab, cause unknown" on "weather/utility pages") was not supported: the lab figures were load-only, and there was no measured group of utility pages. Kept as a record; the work is #5.

The pages (both ordinary articles, text-type, not utility pages):

Page Field CLS (real users) Lab CLS quoted Lab method
Weather forecast article: https://www.prajavani.net/agriculture/climate/karnataka-weather-forecast-rain-alert-districts-list-4323207 0.54 (Search Console Core Web Vitals; Search Console reports URL groups, so this may be the group's value, not this URL's own) 0.095–0.100, with or without Taboola load only, no scroll
Feature article: https://www.prajavani.net/art-culture/article-features/peace-auto-demands-karnataka-ratna-for-ambareesh-and-shankar-nag-station-naming-4376516 0.33 (CrUX p75 for this URL, 16 Nov 2026; #39) 0.03 DevTools trace, load only, no scroll

Why the gap is not unexplained: field CLS counts shifts during the whole visit, including while the reader scrolls. #5's lab test (59 PV URLs) found CLS above 0.1 only after scrolling (load-only: 1 of 59), with the Taboola below-article feed as the largest shift on 55 of 59; scrolled to the bottom, articles measured 0.28–0.67, and blocking Taboola brought that to 0.01–0.11 (docs/QA_test_plan_article_body_and_CLS.md, T4). Both field values sit inside that after-scroll range. Neither page was re-measured with a scroll, so this is the likely explanation, not a confirmed one.

Fix: #5 (reserve height for the Taboola feed, mount it lazily). Verify: after #5 ships, field CLS for these two URLs and the 67.7K-URL group in Search Console ~28 days later. Optional: web-vitals attribution logging if field CLS stays above 0.1 after #5.